Gimbal vs Pan/Tilt Head

Custom Jib Crane: Gimbal VS. Pan/Tilt Head

5/19/2020

Our jib equipped with our gimbal

Among some of the bigger equipment upgrades we made in the later part of 2019 were the upgrades and modifications to our jib crane. Some of these were called for out of necessity, such as the stronger mounting hardware we installed to accommodate the heavier cameras we now use. Other upgrades increased functionality and ease-of-use, such as a tilt-lock mechanism, a monitor mount, and more.

However, there were two upgrades we made which really expanded the creative possibilities our jib provides. These two upgrades are gimbal mounting hardware and a motorized pan/tilt head. We often get asked about what types of shots these modifications allow us to produce, what the differences in the two are, how do we decide which one to use, and what our thoughts are about both.

Today, we'll not only tell, but also show you some samples of the cool camera moves these modifications allow us to capture with our jib crane. We'll also share some of the pros and cons, as well as our own thoughts and opinions of both of them. If you have a jib crane, these upgrades are worth looking into.

An important thing to note is that these two modifications can't be used together at the same time on the jib. I mean, you COULD mount the gimbal on the pan/tilt head and mount the resulting monstrosity on the jib...but....why? If you have both options available to you, you'll need to choose the one that you feel is best for the shot you are trying to produce.

But first, what do we even mean by gimbal or motorized pan/tilt head? If you're not familiar with what one or both of these are, here's pictures of each one mounted on our jib crane.

3-Axis Gimbal

Motorized Pan/Tilt Head

Later on, we'll look at some of the specific differences in functionality between these two pieces of equipment.

What Kind of Shots can they Produce?

We often get asked for sample footage of shots produced by our jib crane using a gimbal or pan/tilt head. Below you can see some shots produced using both of them. These are by no means the only camera moves which are possible. You can combine any number of different moves to create an incredibly graceful cinematic motion shot using a jib with a gimbal or pan/tilt head. There are an astronomical number of ways to combine all of the movement into epic, eye-candy camera moves.

Think about how many dimensions the camera is moving in all at once. The jib arm itself moves freely in two dimensions (vertical and horizontal axis). It moves through the third dimension (Z axis) in a limited capacity when you raise or lower the jib arm. It brings the camera closer to the subject as the arm becomes parallel with the ground and more distant as the arm approaches its maximum vertical angle. The jib head itself tilts up and down, automatically in sync with the jib arm, or manually using the manual tilt handle. The you have a motorized 2-axis or 3-axis motion control system mounted on there. Creating really epic camera moves with a motion system this complex requires and equal amount of planning and playing around with it. You can plan a shot out in your head an think it's going to be poetry in motion, but then when you actually do it, the moves just don't jive together. Other times you may just be messing around shooting some test shots and you stumble across an sweet move you can't stop re-watching. We usually discover a new move we never thought of before each time we film with this jib system.

Here are just a few examples of some simple jib motion shots we captured using the jib crane with the pan/tilt head and the gimbal.

Pan/Tilt Head Vs. Gimbal COMPARISON

The video below shows clips captured using the motorized pan/tilt head and clips captured using the gimbal on our jib crane.

4k Pan/Tilt Head Shots

Here's a few additional sample shots captured with our jib crane equipped with the motorized pan/tilt head. These shots were all filmed in 4K UHD using our Canon 5D Mk IV.

As you can see, there are a number of similarities in the shots both the pan/tilt head and gimbal can produce. It can be hard to distinguish between them unless you really know what to look for in the movement of the shots.

The most obvious difference is that the pan/tilt head has a bit more ridged movement than the gimbal, which is to be expected. The gimbal also provides a bit more stability, ironing out slight bumps and wobbles caused from the movement of the crane. Again, this is to be expected since the gimbal actively stabilizes the camera. There are a ton of very unique camera moves you can perform with a set up like this. They all have that signature "jib shot" feeling to them, which I personally find very pleasing visually.

The jib lets you go from high angles to low angles or vice-versa in one smooth motion. It also adds a slight arch to the move. With tools like the gimbal or pan/tilt head, you can add yet another layer of smooth, dynamic motion to your shot. One way to create a cool shot is by countering directions of movement; for example, if you're panning the crane left, pan the camera right at the same speed while keeping a steady track on your subject.

Like we said, there are tons of creative moves you can do with this type of jib setup, but we'll do an in-depth look at those in a future post. Right now, let's look more closely at the differences between these two pieces of equipment. First, you need to know what equipment we're actually using here.

The Gimbal

DJI Ronin-M

The gimbal we use on our jib crane is the DJI Ronin-M. We actually owned this gimbal for a few months before coming up with the idea of mounting it on the jib crane.

The Ronin-M can support medium sized cameras and has a number of additional features such as power outputs to power other gear like monitors and lights. It is powered by a detachable, rechargeable intelligent battery pack. DJI offers a mobile app which allows you to adjust the gimbal motor setting, run auto-calibrations, and control other functions easily on the go.

The feature which makes this gimbal well-suited for use with a jib crane are its dual-operator capabilities. This allows the gimbal to be controlled remotely via a handheld remote controller. It is possible for one person to operate both the jib and gimbal remote alone. However, it is much more effective when one operator controls the jib and a second operator controls the gimbal.

In order to use the Ronin-M with the jib, we purchased a Ronin-M mounting adapter which allows the gimbal to be mounted to other pieces of equipment with standard mounting screws. We also had to get an extension mounting plate for our jib to mount the gimbal far enough away from the head of the crane so that the back has enough clearance to move freely

Ronin-M Info

Mounting Adapter Info

Motorized Pan/Tilt Head

ProAm USA Tigertilt

The Tigertilt motorized pan/tilt head from ProAm USA was specifically designed to be used with jib cranes. It is controlled by a pressure-sensitive joystick controller which can mount right onto the body of the jib. The remote is connected to the pan/tilt head via a 20' 4-pin XLR cable. The whole device is powered by a single BP915 rechargeable battery. This battery lasts us a full day of shooting on just a single charge. The battery plate comes with velcro strips to allow it to be easily secured to the side of the crane or the side of the remote. Cameras can be mounted securely to the top or bottom of the mounting plate. You can see in the photo that our C100 Mark II is mounted upside down on it.

The pan/tilt head itself can be mounted in an over-slung or under-slung fashion on the jib. It can also be mounted to most any other equipment as well, such as tripods and sliders. The single joystick controller can easily be operated with one hand while controlling the jib crane with the other hand. This makes it perfect for single operator use. It is made of high-quality aluminum which limits the weight it adds to the jib meaning only a small increase in counterweight is needed.

Tigertilt Info

The Jib Crane

ProAm USA Orion DVC210

At the core of our jib rig is a ProAm Orion 12' jib crane. It is actually an 8' foot model with a 4' extension. This allows us to reduce the crane's size when needed, such as filming in tight spaces or with low ceiling height. The jib can be mounted on various tripod setups which increases it's versatility. The head's tilt is kept in sync with the crane by a pin which can be removed to control the tilt manually.

You can use the crane on its own without a gimbal or pan/tilt head. You just won't be able to pan the camera independently of the jib. We used the stock crane with the 4' extension by itself for over a year before adding any other accessories. The crane by itself isn't too heavy, the body is made from high-quality aluminum. Once balanced properly with counterweights, you can get smooth movements effortlessly.

Setting up the crane by itself doesn't require any tools and takes one person about 5 minutes. The other attachments we use increase the setup time to 10-15 minutes.

Orion DVC210 Info

4' Extension Info

Pros and Cons

3-Axis Gimbal (Ronin-M)

Pros

Wireless control
Advanced stabilization
Advanced functions (i.e. pan locking on Ronin-M)
Solid stabilizer system you'll use all the time, on or off the jib
Almost no operating noise when balanced properly

Cons

Difficult using on jib without two operators
Requires additional mounting hardware
Control sensitivity must be fine-tuned to get fluid movement
Must re-balance after each lens change

Pan/Tilt Head (TigerTilt)

Pros

Built for jibs
No balancing required
Single operator use - Easily controlled by jib operator
Pressure-sensitive joystick simplifies speed control for fluid moves
Can support large cameras
360 degree range of motion for pan & tilt

Cons

Noisy operation - even the slowest will be caught by on-camera mic
Wired control means more cable management. Head can become entangled in the cables if they aren't properly secured
Limited uses other than on jib
2-axis only (no roll axis)

Vertical Divider

Both of these are awesome additions to any crane! We started with the gimbal first, because we already had the Ronin-M for a while. If you are looking to get one or the other of these for your crane, unless you use a jib everyday on your own, consider going with a gimbal first. You will get more use out of the gimbal because it can be used all the time, even when you aren't using a jib. If you often work alone, using the gimbal remote and jib together is difficult, but very doable with practice.

Keep the pan/tilt head in mind as well though later down the road, especially for those of you that are typically solo operators.

Pan/Tilt Head with Roll Axis

There are a number of options available to you if you are looking for a gimbal or motorized pan/tilt head. As we noted in the pros and cons above, the Tigertilt doesn't offer a roll axis for performing dutch roll moves. This probably isn't a move you'll use often, but it can be nice to have the option to do so.

The SHOOTVILLA 3-Axis Motorized Dutch Roll 360° Pan Tilt Head is a motorized pan/tilt head which gives you this option. It does cost more than the Tigertilt, which is to be expected since you are getting a third axis of movement.

Shootvilla Pan/Tilt Head Info

The creative possibilities unlocked when you combine one of these motion control systems with your jib are truly amazing. A bit of practice is needed to get the hang of coordinating the movements, but it's well worth it. You'll be able to create one-of-a-kind cinematic motion shots which can't be produced with any other system.

Let us know if you have any questions about our jib or any of the equipment we've discussed today, and let us know what you'd like us to write about next!

We'll be adding more posts featuring this gear and more in the future so check back with us soon. Subscribe to our newsletter to stay up-to-date with our latest blog posts! Now get out there and create!

RSS Feed